Did you know Roth IRAs actually have two different five-year clocks—and confusing them can cost you a 10% early distribution penalty? In this video, FinStream’s Robert Powell sits down with Andy Ives, IRA expert with Ed Slott and Company, to demystify the Roth conversion clock using FinStream’s Roth Clock Lens tool.
Walking through interactive case studies, Andy demonstrates how each Roth conversion starts its own separate five-year clock, what happens if you pull funds out early, and why turning 59½ changes the rules entirely.
What You’ll Learn About the Roth Conversion Clock
- The Two Roth Clocks Explained: The critical difference between the 5-year forever clock (for tax-free earnings) and the 5-year conversion clock (for penalty-free converted principal).
- Under Age 59½ Case Study: Why a 40-year-old converting $100,000 and withdrawing $30,000 two years later owes zero income tax—but gets hit with a $3,000 (10%) early distribution penalty.
- Multiple Conversions: Why doing a second Roth conversion in a later year starts a brand-new, separate five-year clock for those specific converted dollars.
- Over Age 59½ Case Study: Why the 5-year conversion clock disappears once you reach age 59½, and how taking a partial withdrawal lets you access converted principal completely tax- and penalty-free even if your forever clock hasn’t finished ticking.
- Strategic Planning Opportunity: How to use a Roth conversion ladder to access retirement funds penalty-free before age 59½.
Interactive Tool and Resources
Try the interactive tool featured in this video at finstream.tv/rothclocklens, and explore more Roth IRA and retirement tax resources from Ed Slott and Company at irahelp.com.
